Privacy Cases
League of Women Voters v. DHS (Modified SAVE System)
1:25-cv-03501
US District Court for the District of Columbia
Challenging the Trump Administration’s unlawful expansion and misuse of the SAVE system as a national citizenship data bank
Summary
In September 2025, a coalition of plaintiffs comprising the League of Women Voters, League of Women Voters of Virginia, League of Women Voters of Louisiana, League of Women Voters of Louisiana Education Fund, EPIC, and five individuals, filed suit against the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and Social Security Administration (SSA) challenging the Trump administration’s unlawful expansion and misuse of the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) system as a national citizenship data bank. The government is encouraging states to use this system to purge people from voter rolls and unlawfully open criminal investigations. The case also challenged DHS’s broader and illegal consolidation of personal information from across federal agencies.
The plaintiffs are represented by Democracy Forward, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), and Fair Elections Center. The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
Background
In January 2025, the Trump administration created the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) and tasked it with implementing the President’s agenda, which included government-wide consolidation of personal data. In March 2025, President Trump issued an executive order directing federal agency heads to take all necessary steps to ensure that federal officials, including DOGE personnel, would “have full and prompt access to all unclassified agency records, data, software systems, and information technology systems” to combat fraud, waste, and abuse. The executive order includes directing agency heads to authorize the consolidation and sharing of unclassified agency records and take necessary steps to ensure “unfettered access to comprehensive data from all State programs that receive Federal funding, including . . . data generated by those programs but maintained by third-party databases.”
In the same month, President Trump issued another executive order directing DHS to provide State and local officials access to systems that would verify citizenship and immigration status of individuals registering or who have already registered to vote. The executive order directs the Department of Justice (DOJ) to prioritize prosecuting noncitizens registered to vote using information from DHS databases, regardless of whether or not they actually voted.
In carrying out the President’s orders, DOGE, DHS, and the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) secretly consolidated Americans’ sensitive personal data from multiple agencies without the statutorily required notice to the public and Congress. DOGE and DHS repurposed pre-existing USCIS technology to pool individuals’ sensitive data across agencies and create a searchable national citizenship data system that can verify immigration status and U.S. citizenship. The agencies overhauled USCIS’s Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) system, which originally allowed federal, state, tribal, and local government agencies to confirm citizenship and immigration status prior to granting benefits and licenses. The overhauled system now allows bulk searches of American’s sensitive data and also accesses Social Security Administration (SSA) citizenship databases. Prior to the changes, the SAVE system was limited in scope and functionality. It did not access databases on U.S.-born citizens or allow searches of Social Security numbers (SSN). Since SSA data is not regularly updated and relies on SSN-holders to update their records with the agency, the SSA data is known to be unreliable. As recently as 2023, in fact, the SSA stated that its records are not definitive and cautioned against relying on SSA data to verify citizenship or immigration status.
In addition to overhauling the SAVE system, DHS pooled interagency data into the USCIS Data Lake and expanded the scope and functionality of the system. The USCIS Data Lake is a centralized repository of large volumes of data that is ingested from different sources. There is currently no published System of Records Notice (SORN) for this system and the last Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA) concerning the Data Lake was published in 2018. DHS is using the Data Lake to pool and/or cross check non-DHS agency data records about U.S. citizens and residents against the Data Lake. This Data Lake contains millions of Americans’ Social Security numbers, tax information, medical records, biometric data, and children’s case files.
Neither DOGE or DHS has conducted any assessment of the privacy implications or risks of error when overhauling these systems.
Plaintiffs’ Lawsuit
On September 30, 2025, EPIC and the coalition filed suit against DHS.
The complaint alleged that the administration has unlawfully transformed DHS’s SAVE system into a national citizenship database, pooling unreliable SSA data that is now being used by some states to purge voter rolls and open criminal investigations. The complaint also alleged that the administration built a USCIS “data lake” that combines records from the Internal Revenue Service, SSA, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, U.S. Department of Labor, and state voter registration databases.
The administration’s unlawful data consolidation threatens to disenfranchise eligible voters and subject Americans to unwarranted investigations and creates unprecedented security risks by aggregating enormous volumes of sensitive personal information. The lawsuit asks the court to block DHS’s and SSA’s unlawful consolidation and use of personal data.
The complaint details how DHS has failed to comply with key federal laws regulating the collection, use, retention, and disclosure of personal information. DHS failed to publish any applicable SORNs mandated by the Privacy Act of 1974 and PIAs mandated by section 208 of the E-Government Act of 2002. These failures impact people whose personal information are in these interagency data systems and organizations like EPIC from learning what data is being collected, how it will be used, who will have access, how it will be stored and secured, and how individuals can exercise their rights of data access and correction. Individuals and organizations have also been denied their statutory right to comment on the relevant collection(s) and system(s) of personal information.
States such as Louisiana, Virginia, and Texas are using the unlawfully expanded SAVE system to systematically purge voter rolls and open criminal investigations on purported non-citizens for alleged illegal voting. The Trump administration continues to encourage states to use the overhauled SAVE system to identify noncitizens registered to vote.
“This country was founded on the principle that government has no business arbitrarily intruding in our private affairs,” said John Davisson, EPIC’s Director of Litigation. “Yet this administration is trampling on our privacy at the grandest scale, illegally hoarding our sensitive personal information and threatening our most cherished rights. The law is clear: no national data bank. Together we’ll put a stop to this in court.”
On October 7, 2025, the plaintiffs requested a preliminary injunction to stop the administration from moving forward with its data consolidation plans with the SAVE system while the case is being considered. The database is pooling unreliable SSA citizenship data, which states are using to illegally and inaccurately purging voter rolls and open criminal investigations ahead of the upcoming elections. The court (Judge Sparkle L. Sooknanan) set a hearing on the motion for October 28, 2025. While the court declined to grant a preliminary injunction in November 2025, our fight continues on the merits.
Following this lawsuit, DHS and SSA belatedly published System of Records Notices regarding the overhauled SAVE system. Both notices triggered a public comment period under the Privacy Act, and an overwhelming amount of public opposition flooded the agencies. EPIC led two coalitions to submit comments to both DHS and SSA opposing the government’s unlawful expansion of the SAVE system.
On January 21, 2026, the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint detailing how the agency’s actions violates American’s privacy and voting rights as well as calling attention to the thousands of public comments opposing the illegal expansion of the SAVE system. The amended complaint also identifies U.S. citizens incorrectly purged from voter rolls and those who were threatened with removal because of unlawful changes to the SAVE system.
On March 12, 2026, the plaintiffs filed a motion for summary judgement arguing that agency did not have statutory authority to expand SAVE into a national citizenship database to flag and purge eligible voters. This illegal transformation and use of SAVE also violated the Privacy Act’s required notice-and-comment requirement.
On June 22, 2026, the district court granted plaintiff’s motion for summary judgement, ruling that the government’s expansion of SAVE to check voter eligibility was unlawful. The court held that DHS violated the Social Security Act, the Privacy Act, and the Administrative Procedure Act. The district court vacated and set aside the overhauled SAVE system and the two SORNs issued by the government as part of the overhaul. The court ruled that DHS had “knowingly trampled on the privacy rights of American citizens in a manner that threatens the sacred right to vote.” The court’s order took effect immediately.
On June 25, 2026, the administration appealed the decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. On July 1, 2026, they filed a motion to stay the district court’s decision pending appeal.
On July 8, 2026, the district court denied the government’s motion for a stay. The court stated that the government not only engaged in “gamesmanship” and “mischaracterized” the court’s reasoning in seeking to block its decision, but the entire situation is entirely “self-inflicted,” and its litigation tactics “make a mockery of separation of powers.”
On September 4, 2026, the D.C. Circuit denied the government’s motion for a stay and upheld the lower court’s ruling that the modified SAVE system is illegal. Shortly after the appeals court denial, the administration sought an emergency stay from the U.S. Supreme Court to let states continue to use the expanded SAVE system to conduct voter registration verification and potential remove eligible voters from voter rolls.
On September 25, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a 6-3 decision granting the government’s request for a stay of the district court decision, allowing the use of the SAVE database while the government’s appeal continues. The National Voter Registration Act, however, prohibits mass voter purges during a 90-day “quiet period” before a federal election. This unsigned order came down within the 90-day quiet period before the 2026 midterm elections, which means that states cannot use the modified SAVE system for mass voter purges ahead of the election. The underlying merits fight over the legality of the SAVE system remains pending in the D.C. Circuit.
EPIC’s Interest
For decades, EPIC has made extensive use of public notices and records concerning the collection, use, retention, and transfer of personal information by federal agencies. These include Systems of Records Notices mandated by the Privacy Act, Information Collection Review documentation mandated by the Paperwork Reduction Act, and Privacy Impact Assessments mandated by section 208 of the E-Government Act. EPIC uses the information from these records to routinely submit public comments, craft targeted Freedom of Information Requests, undertake research, and conduct public education and advocacy efforts.
EPIC also has a long history of protecting voter privacy and election integrity. Notably, EPIC successfully challenged the unlawful collection of personal voter data by the Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity. The suit led to the halting of the unlawful gathering of personal voter data, discontinued use of an unsafe computer server, deletion of illegally obtained voter data obtained, and disbanding of the Commission.
Since January 2025, EPIC has closely tracked the Trump administration’s efforts to consolidate and increase its access to personal information maintained by federal and state governments. Over that time, EPIC has published analysis, developed public resources, provided expertise to lawmakers and members of the press, undertaken litigation, and engaged in extensive advocacy concerning the privacy, security, and legal risks of the Trump administration’s data consolidation activities. This case is one of our efforts in fighting against the Trump administration’s privacy abuses.
Case Documents
League of Women Voters, et al. v. DHS, No. 25-03501 (D.D.C. Filed Sep. 30, 2025)
- Complaint (Sep. 30, 2025)
- Motion for Preliminary Injunction (Oct. 7, 2025)
- Motion to Certify Class (Oct. 7, 2025)
- Memorandum Opinion and Order Granting Pseudonymity (Oct. 10, 2025)
- Consent Motion to File Amicus Brief by Sen. Alex Padilla & Gary Peters (Oct. 10, 2025)
- Amicus Brief by Sen. Alex Padilla & Gary Peters (Oct. 15, 2025)
- DHS Memorandum in Opposition to Preliminary Injunction (Oct. 22, 2025)
- DHS Memorandum in Opposition to Certify Class (Oct. 22, 2025)
- Consent Motion to File Amicus Brief by Campaign Legal Center (Oct. 24, 2025)
- Amicus Brief by Campaign Legal Center (Oct. 24, 2025)
- LWV Reply to DHS’s Opposition to Preliminary Injunction (Oct. 24, 2025)
- LWV Reply to DHS’s Opposition to Certify Class (Oct. 24, 2025)
- Emergency Motion to Intervene as Defendant by State of Texas (Oct. 27, 2025)
- LWV Supplemental Memorandum to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (Oct. 29, 2025)
- LWV Notice to Withdraw Motion to Certify Class (Oct. 29, 2025)
- LWV Opposition to State of Texas’s Emergency Motion to Intervene (Oct. 31, 2025)
- DHS Response to State of Texas’s Emergency Motion to Intervene (Oct. 31, 2025)
- DHS Response to LWV’s Supplemental Memorandum to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (Nov. 3, 2025)
- State of Texas Reply to LWV’s Opposition Motion to Intervene (Nov. 3, 2025)
- Memorandum Opinion Denying Preliminary Injunction (Nov. 17, 2025)
- Order Denying Preliminary Injunction (Nov. 17, 2025)
- LWV Amended Complaint (Jan. 21, 2026)
- Notice of Filing Administrative Record (Mar. 3, 2026)
- Notice of Filing Corrected Administrative Record (Mar. 11, 2026)
- LWV Motion for Summary Judgement (Mar. 12, 2026)
- Amicus Brief by Travis County Tax Assessor Collector, County Clerk, and Travis County, Texas (Mar. 20, 2026)
- Amicus Brief by Texas Civil Rights Project (Mar. 27, 2026)
- Amicus Brief by Lawyers Defending American Democracy, Inc. (Mar. 31, 2026)
- Amicus Brief by Service Employees International Union (SEIU) and UnidosUS (Apr. 1, 2026)
- DHS Motion to Dismiss and Opposition to LWV’s Motion for Summary Judgment (Apr. 2, 2026)
- LWV Notice of Executive Order 14399 (Apr. 4, 2026)
- Order Granting Texas’s Motion to Intervene (Apr. 6, 2026)
- Amicus Brief by Campaign Legal Center, Center for Media and Democracy, Common Cause, and Protect Democracy Project (Apr. 6, 2026)
- Amicus Brief by ACLU (Apr. 14, 2026)
- Texas Motion to Dismiss LWV’s Amended Complaint (Apr. 23, 2026)
- LWV Reply in Support of LWV’s Motion for Summary Judgment and Opposition of DHS’s Motion to Dismiss (Apr. 24, 2026)
- LWV Opposition to Texas’s Motion to Dismiss LWV’s Amended and Supplemental Complaint (May 8, 2026)
- Texas Reply in Support of its Motion to Dismiss LWV’s Amended and Supplemental Complaint (May 16, 2026)
- DHS Reply in Support for Texas’s Motion to Dismiss or Alt for Summary Judgment (May 29, 2026)
- LWV Notice Regarding Implementation of EO 14399 (June 8, 2026)
- DHS Notice and Response to LWV’s Notice (June 9, 2026)
- Memorandum Opinion Granting LWV Motion for Summary Judgment (June 22, 2026)
- Order Granting LWV Motion for Summary Judgment (June 22, 2026)
- DHS Motion to Stay Pending Appeal (July 1, 2026)
- LWV Response to Motion to Stay Pending Appeal (July 7, 2026)
- DHS Reply in Support of Motion to Stay Pending Appeal (July 7, 2026)
- Amicus Brief by Arizona State President Warren Petersen and Arizona Speaker of the House of Representatives Steve Montenegro (July 7, 2026)
- Memorandum Opinion Denying DHS Motion to Stay Pending Appeal (July 8, 2026)
- Order Denying DHS Motion to Stay (July 8, 2026)
- LWV Motion to Enforce Summary Judgment (July 14, 2026)
- DHS Opposition to LWV Motion to Enforce Summary Judgement (July 16, 2026)
- LWV Reply in Support to Enforce Summary Judgement (July 17, 2026)
D.C. Court of Appeals No. 26-5243
- Statement of Issues (July 7, 2026)
- DHS Motion to Stay Pending Appeal (July 8, 2026)
- LWV Opposition to DHS Motion to Stay Pending Appeal (July 16, 2026)
- DHS Reply in Support of Motion to Stay Pending Appeal (July 20, 2026)
- Order Denying Stay Pending Appeal (Sep. 4, 2026)
U.S. Supreme Court No. 26A308
- Solicitor General’s Stay Application (Sep 8. 2026)
- LWV Opposition to Application for a Stay (Sep. 15, 2026)
- Per Curium Order Granting Stay (Sep. 25, 2026)
Support Our Work
EPIC's work is funded by the support of individuals like you, who allow us to continue to protect privacy, open government, and democratic values in the information age.
Donate